Community Archive

🧵 View Thread

🧵 Thread (8 tweets)

Placeholder
Emmett Shear@eshear• over 1 year ago

We have lived through something akin to The Great Renunciation, except instead of men renouncing interest in fashion it’s all of society renouncing interest in design. Buildings are boxes. Everything is in white or black. Mass degreebelization. (Reversal may be coming tho!) https://t.co/QWQKlDZZwi

2.5K 181
1/10/2024
Placeholder
Tyler Alterman@TylerAlterman• over 1 year ago
Replying to @eshear

@eshear Been wondering about this. Any theory for why? https://t.co/qrItYlWEu6

Placeholder
Tyler Alterman@TylerAlterman• about 2 years ago

We used to carve creatures, gods, and people into building facades *everywhere* for thousands of years…until last century when we mostly just stopped. Now it would be seen as extravagant to cover a building in little beings. Why did our tastes change so quickly? https://t.co/QpWx5q6ZZp

Quoted tweet image 1
325 14
10 0
1/10/2024
Placeholder
Emmett Shear@eshear• over 1 year ago
Replying to @TylerAlterman

@TylerAlterman Lots of theories, none that I love. I don’t think we know why the great renunciation happened either. Some deep thing in our collective psyche…

7 0
1/10/2024
Placeholder
Tyler Alterman@TylerAlterman• over 1 year ago
Replying to @eshear

@eshear Which of the low-confidence theories are you most confident in?

4 0
1/10/2024
Placeholder
Tyler Alterman@TylerAlterman• over 1 year ago
Replying to @TylerAlterman

@eshear One new theory I just made up: maybe today’s elite are specialized for global competition, which much more rewards efficiency, cost-cutting, etc and this is reflected in their aesthetic tastes even for their own homes, and they set the aesthetic for everyone else

1 0
1/10/2024
Placeholder
Emmett Shear@eshear• over 1 year ago
Replying to @TylerAlterman

@TylerAlterman - digital architecture and design are more profitable and hoovering up all the talent - anti-decoration aesthetic fashion trend (brutalism and descendants) has dominated top prestige design stuff - cheaper w modern techniques - more regulation = winners good at that not beauty

4 0
1/10/2024
Placeholder
Emmett Shear@eshear• over 1 year ago
Replying to @TylerAlterman

@TylerAlterman Paul’s theory seems reasonable too https://t.co/Wd6RyqX3dB

3 0
1/11/2024
Placeholder
Tyler Alterman@TylerAlterman• over 1 year ago
Replying to @eshear

@eshear Perhaps true for THAT level of ornament, but def not for ornament in general

3 0
1/11/2024