🧵 View Thread
🧵 Thread (55 tweets)
Epic thread exploring various narratives around moralizing food and how it is used to control populations.Cholesterol (fried food) moralizing is particularly interesting; the classic test for that in blood is flawed and suggests many false positives. https://t.co/GrepvVwoX3 https://t.co/nWOyqfgjCE
Exploring my own genetics as it relates to cholesterol processing (Multiple Sclerosis appears to be a disorder of cholesterol in the brain) has unearthed all sorts of weird variations that are particularly high among European populations. Likely due to to effects of the plague?
A ritualized moralizing around food + perspectives on what one ought to eat might be a good idea for a particular group. But to project these beliefs onto other populations via positions of privilege, claiming to help the public health? I can't see it as anything but ignorance.
To me it is about as dumb as forcing everyone to wear glasses because the privileged class in a position of power happen to have myopia genes.I know we have hipster glasses now - with people wearing frames with no lenses. imagine if that was done under a sense of public health?
In the past it might have made sense to assume populations were at risk for a particular ailment. E.g. people who's lineages stem from malaria prone places are at risk for sickle-cell.But with modern genetic, this *assumption* is starting to show cracks.https://t.co/vB7JHATHUR https://t.co/5JLwT7vsow
To get a clear head around how these disease things work, you've got to have a bullshit sensor tuned to sniff out when all of this systemic racism stuff influences research. Sometimes, like Freud's research on autism in boys, it can be a tainting factor for entire fields.
Even now, I see evidence of this kind of moralizing influencing narratives. When researching the history of vagal nerve stimulation and constipation I find all sorts of negative puritanical frames projected on the past. You have to sniff that out too. https://t.co/Z93U6wICL4
If we assume that the population of people Kellogg was studying had some kind of serotonin imbalance leading to constipation (like I seem to have). It makes more sense that he was sticking yogurt (probiotics) up peoples butts, and obsessed with vagal stimulation and sunlight.
If you view all of that thru modern lenses of him doing sexually perverse things, you're going to miss that. You're going to project your own morals, from a position of privilege and get the same dynamic. A privileged population using assumptions about biology to oppress another.
I say this not to entrench a belief of genetic differences. The last thing I want to imply is any kind of superiority or eugenics or any kind of nazi level survival of the fittest bullshit. My entire point is that this kind of bullshit is a result of that.https://t.co/2Zxo0VdpXJ
When I see any hint that one group should be forced into eating a certain way, or perform a certain ritual, my skin crawls. My entire interest in personalized medicine is self determination. I've lived my life being told wrong things. Cultural moors assuming what is good for me.
I find myself within my own oppressed group - neurodivergent, poverty, etc.I think in the past I'd be seen as a changeling, murdered for being a demon.If I even lived that long.We're still exorcising demons from autistics, just under a different name.https://t.co/mLfNC2uN4X
I don't have claims of racial oppression, but its the same pattern. Society forming belief systems and emergent systemic friction that act as rebuffs against those who don't fit the mold.It is insidious, pervasive, and I suspect often weaponized.https://t.co/JzynTQj5kA
Our society is monstrous.https://t.co/xuOvJZyTzZ
"Evolutionary biology is in part a historical science – and as such we have to live with some ambiguity: we can detect the footprints of past selection – but we may never know for sure which phenotypes selection acted on."https://t.co/VI1UpJj5va
*SCURVY*https://t.co/21NrNoivdV
FUCKING SCURVY"populations that are often cut off from adequate diets. In addition to the low-income housing [...]don’t necessarily indicate a resurgence of scurvy, where and how this old disease is turning up says a lot about nutrition in America today"https://t.co/rGOe3RgXM4
"Victims suffered general weakness and joint pain. Their bodies showed bruises from internal bleeding. Their breath turned foul, their gums bled and their teeth fell out."https://t.co/G9LWIs4Ag1
“Veritatem inquirenti, semel in vita de omnibus, quantum fieri potest, esse dubitandum” ― René Descarteshttps://t.co/OIdaTVcVcJ
Tear down.Build up.Tear up.https://t.co/Q6fTkMUMBY
"We're risk averse and scared of new things. That makes sense from a survival perspective, but it makes for lousy science."https://t.co/5QeoDXWxyg https://t.co/ImS7tyVscc
"They are smart, educated, and lucky to live in this modern world. So why is it that they are both overweight, with risk factors for serious chronic diseases?"https://t.co/jDCksUXcud https://t.co/9bjYB69bsG
Also includes the myth of "the outgroup", reinforced by a society subject to survivalship bias inherent to the struggle of gene and meme flow. Who put those myths there? Do you trust as holy truth? Toxic koans meant to destroy a tribe also exist as myth.https://t.co/AiYDk635YE
We are all infectious agents trying to spread our genetic ooze. Monsters taking shape in the night and telling scary stories about past iterations of ourselves. Memetic scaffolds built to deify or demonize the past. Escaping reality thru narrative tunnels.https://t.co/WE9r2rpTAx
Myth as truth.Truth as myth.https://t.co/RZQReqwfp8
I stumbled my way into learning genetics and evolution because I had this funny idea on how tradition and myth operate to form entire societies.Turns out there is an entire body of knowledge about how society is a body of knowlege: https://t.co/fuImnR9vTChttps://t.co/drb4FVnHoF
Of course everybody goes and takes functionalism seriously does the same damn thing they did with evolution; uses these theories to justify their might-makes-right rhetorical bullshit. Superior species, superior society? Chosen ones? Hypocrites.https://t.co/fuImnR9vTC https://t.co/t2hERFc93F
My way is the best way? It's all just self-serving hypocritical bullshit. Even my own. We're all just telling myths to convince each which of us is worthy of not being murdered. We've learned nothing.https://t.co/HzUkddHOSt
Even anti-capitalist/anti-colonialst types don't realize they are just promulgating a story derived via Durkheim vis-a-vis a British colonialist narrative about evolution. All perpetuating different versions of the same myth and fighting over who's right.https://t.co/WqEUIU5qgF
What stories are the machines that follow in our wake going to tell about us?https://t.co/rI0t3jxcgX
Even myths within our own popular culture on the subject get this wrong.Mammals? A Natural equilibrium? My ass!Only thing stopping meerkats from overpopulating? They ritually murder each other. Murder Squirrels. https://t.co/vx0Bu9EkzZNaturalistic fallacy for $1000 Alex: https://t.co/TBhNDzJ0oQ
Worshiping myths used to justify who is worthy of being murdered. Starved. Destroyed. Shamed.https://t.co/1lxxnA1DJ9
Same shit, different day.https://t.co/iV8nVsKbC5
Telling you where you ought to poop.https://t.co/snerARRd5L
Worshiping food.https://t.co/cAov8G0gVz
Murder monkeys stories on who should live or die? -> really just an obscure way hint at selective breeding."The fact that some dogs were ritually buried while others were butchered suggests a complex set of beliefs regarding the place of dogs in society."https://t.co/WdylWWnvvc
Framing eugenics as a form of ritual sacrifice? A self serving motive perpetuated by a species known to throw deformed babies off cliffs.Of course we seek status, those who weren't high status were ostracized for minor slights and left to die.https://t.co/31pdqSUCFs
Ostracized for slights and left to die? What are you talking about Ape? We don't do that...https://t.co/6LEQoL5jtc
"Oh look, this homeless person is actually a real human being worthy of respect." -> so rare that it makes headlines.https://t.co/7hKuiArT8Q
That person doesn't have a job?They are lower class - part of the precariate.I don't need to care about them."Fuck you got mine."https://t.co/9Ib8IpHFeX
Stories we tell ourselves about other people to justify their death."For people without severe mental illness, homelessness is often temporary. But those with mental illness..."https://t.co/237qpSZPmK
Stories we tell ourselves about other people."Carrie’s mother had been involuntarily institutionalized for being “feebleminded” and “promiscuous.” Carrie was assumed to have inherited these traits, and was sterilized after giving birth."https://t.co/g0fyWcNBmw
Giving voice to the implications. The story's hidden morals and how they shape our impulses. Murder monkey's so bent on selective breeding that we kill your bloodline's entire future by command of the state.https://t.co/IO1UOgBVRp
I don't like having these ideas in my head. https://t.co/Ua59Jat6do
"... weight gain occurs in up to 40 percent of patients taking medications called second-generation or atypical antipsychotic medications, which have been found effective in controlling major symptoms of schizophrenia." https://t.co/UOiQoUqZrn
"And that to us is striking because it counters the simple narrative that everything's getting better. There are some things that are getting worse. And of course again the question might be: why? What is specific about body-weight attitude?"https://t.co/izJ5WTzh1R
Darkness haunts my thoughts like the Titan Cronus eating his own children.https://t.co/JGdepMf3Tx
Friendly reminder that most child abductions are done by people who know the child, often parental. Your husband/wife will likely still have the app on the phone.https://t.co/bHy10kYs7mBoth my parents were paranoid the other was going to steal me away. It was super obnoxious.
Life feeds on life feeds on life feeds on...Like a snake eating it's own tail to heal it self.Or a hamster devouring it's sons & daughters to try to avoid starvation long enough to survive until better times.https://t.co/qKYjWsMxo7
There is a pun here. Deep mythos.Saturnalia was the sun, until his son displaced him.Father time (Cronus) dying, if only to be reborn again as a babe.https://t.co/IC1LYDEtzh
I want to break free of this cycle.https://t.co/51R4ggct2G