Community Archive

🧵 View Thread

🧵 Thread (12 tweets)

Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago

people will really be like "you invented entire languages for your fantasy world? that pales in effectiveness to my strategy, writing an epic story about medieval tax policy" and then not finish their epic story about medieval tax policy https://t.co/VxRRWk34N4

Tweet image 1
6.3K 358
8/2/2024
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

im mad that hes never gonna finish them because they are in fact fantastic books hes basically pulling it off tbh

842 7
8/2/2024
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

the books are an aggressive deconstruction of chivalric fantasy but he follows it up with a fantastic reconstruction his broken heroes one by one find their paths to salvation

754 10
8/2/2024
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

he doesn't! it's well underway. example. sandor clegane is a dark parody of a knight. he is brutally effective yes, but hideous rather than handsome and deeply cynical. "a knight is for killing." but alone of the chivalry, he protects a distressed damsel https://t.co/jD12NRE2fL https://t.co/sz97ypPy1p

Tweet image 1
346 5
8/2/2024
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

https://t.co/ITRIC6jnaY

Tweet image 1
198 5
8/2/2024
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

the hound isn't as cynical as he presents himself. no one who cares so much for the truth is his contempt for knights is because he tacitly believes in the value of the chivalric ideals they disrespect none of GRRM's True Knights--Sandor, Brienne, Duncan--are legitimate knights

304 5
8/2/2024
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

sansa saves the hound just as he saves her by giving him the opportunity, for once, to be the kind of knight he dreamed of as a boy; to Become Good. and by perceiving that Good, and by believing in him https://t.co/G59a6Ggmpc

Tweet image 1
202 5
8/2/2024
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

irrespective of what martin says in interviews, like the superficially profane hound it's pretty clear he knows what is Worthy in asoiaf martin is trying to find his way to believe in a fallen world https://t.co/OujvuaE5qA https://t.co/WsokrFdgKm

Tweet image 1
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago

put another way, a successful decon/recon cycle is the story of an author charting his own path to salvation https://t.co/Zblat7ZxzC https://t.co/t9L2dDFBid

Quoted tweet image 1
67 2
204 4
8/2/2024
Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

martin reportedly loved chivalric romances as a boy somewhere, in the darkness of dreams, abides the other camelot that can never die. i hope he finds his way home. https://t.co/mYtfNa1OLE

Placeholder
eigenrobot@eigenrobot• over 2 years ago

moreover the *actual* narrator is not some imperialist! it's not even Harun al-Rashid! on the last page of the comic, we zoom out once more, to an even more devastated modern Baghdad and what's this? https://t.co/OBDs5kKOZU

Quoted tweet image 1
153 2
202 4
8/2/2024
Placeholder
Patrick McKenzie@patio11• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

@eigenrobot If I can give you another example, perhaps not from the author but from the show and adored by fan base: people really do like unabashed celebration of masculine virtues being rewarded with in-universe success and the acclaim of others. Exemplar: https://t.co/CtroJiMg2l

Tweet image 1
25 0
8/2/2024
Placeholder
Patrick McKenzie@patio11• about 1 year ago
Replying to @patio11

@eigenrobot This character’s arc is being thrust into leadership before they were ready, spitting defiance at a foreign king, being called to a hopeless war, accepting because honor demanded it, leading men into battle, and then dying heroically having killed her enemy with purest virtue.

38 1
8/2/2024
Placeholder
Phil@blisstweeting• about 1 year ago
Replying to @eigenrobot

@eigenrobot His books might be great (I haven't read them) but this critique in the screenshot annoys me because ffs Tolkien's fantasy is more of a fairy tale than what most of the later fantasy books have become

8 0
8/2/2024